Derivatives:
The Exposure Lab
Recognise an economic exposure before choosing an instrument.
Evaluate whether and how much risk should be hedged.
See margin, MTM, market shocks and imperfect hedges in action.
Distinguish hedging, speculation and arbitrage.
Judge a decision—not simply whether it made money.
Welcome to the Exposure Lab
Today you will not begin with definitions. You will begin with a business problem.
What are you exposed to?
What happens if the market moves?
Do you hedge, speculate or stay exposed?
Was your decision actually good?
Choose your boardroom role
Choose one company. Your team will make decisions from that company's perspective.
Round 1 · Identify the exposure
What is your primary exposure?
Before choosing an instrument: what are you actually trying to protect?
Select the business outcome that matters most in your scenario.
Round 2 · What will you do?
You have no derivative vocabulary yet. That's intentional.
Choose your first risk response.
Round 3 · Market Flash
You made your decision. Now the market gets a vote.
Pause. Don't calculate yet.
Who is celebrating? Who is worried? Who wishes they had hedged?
Your choice has consequences—but not necessarily a single “right answer.”
Write one sentence
Think like a CFO
Your derivative position can lose money while your underlying business exposure improves—or vice versa.
Evaluate the hedge using the total economic position, not the derivative P&L alone.
Outcome Bias Check
Your strategy made money. Does that automatically mean it was a good decision?
Round 4 · Discover the derivative
Now you are given a contract. Your job is to infer what it does.
Customized agreement to transact later at an agreed price.
Standardized exchange-traded contract with margin and daily settlement.
Provides a right, but not an obligation, subject to a premium.
Which idea best describes a hedge?
Round 5 · The margin call
You are now holding a futures position.
🚨 MARGIN CALL
Your margin balance has fallen below the maintenance requirement. You need to top up the account.
Why does this mechanism exist?
What risk did the hedge remove—and what risk remains?
Hedge and exposure do not move perfectly together.
Margin or cash-flow requirements can still matter.
The other side may fail to perform, especially OTC.
Protection can mean giving up some upside.
Execution, documentation and process can fail.
Would you change your decision now?
Round 6 · Hedge, speculate or arbitrage?
Three market participants. Three different motives.
🛡️ Hedger
Has an existing economic exposure and wants to reduce its unwanted price risk.
🎯 Speculator
Chooses to take risk because they expect a market movement.
⚖️ Arbitrageur
Looks for a pricing discrepancy that can potentially be exploited through offsetting positions.
Pricing flash
Nifty theoretical futures value: 25,120. Market futures price: 25,180.
What is the first thing an arbitrageur asks?
Round 7 · The hedge is not perfect
Your exposure and your futures contract move together—but not exactly.
| Start | End | |
|---|---|---|
| Spot | ₹100 | ₹106 |
| Futures | ₹102 | ₹107 |
Think like a CFO
Did the hedge eliminate every bit of risk?
Final Round · The CFO Decision
Your company will receive US$100 million in six months. USD/INR is ₹83 today.
Board question
“What should we do about the FX exposure?”
Before choosing a derivative, what information do you need?
Your final reflection
Your Complete Exposure Lab Debrief
This is your decision trail: what you chose → what happened → how an expert would assess it → what you should learn.
My choice vs. expert assessment
The “expert” answer is intentionally framed as a stronger risk-management choice under the stated facts, not as a universally correct answer. Good derivatives decisions depend on exposure, risk appetite, cost, horizon and flexibility.
Round-by-round decision record
| Round | My decision / response |
|---|---|
| 1 · Identify the exposure | — |
| 2 · Initial risk response | — |
| 3 · Market Flash | — |
| Protection objective | — |
| Outcome Bias Check | — |
| 4 · Derivative concept | — |
| 5 · Margin call | — |
| 6 · Arbitrage decision | — |
| 7 · Basis risk | — |
| Would I change my decision? | — |
| Final CFO · Information required | — |
My decision-quality profile
This is a financial decision-making score, not a trading-profit score.
Final CFO checklist
My reflection
—
Business P&L vs. derivative P&L
Concepts you unlocked
What I discovered
A derivative begins with an economic exposure.
A hedge changes the risk profile; it does not guarantee a profit.
Margin and daily settlement create important cash-flow consequences.
A speculator deliberately takes market risk based on an expectation.
An apparent pricing discrepancy must be tested after costs and constraints.
A hedge can reduce risk without eliminating the mismatch between exposure and hedge.
The derivative is not the starting point.
The exposure is.
You discovered the problem before learning the product.
Exposure → Risk → Decision → Instrument → Outcome
“The derivative is not the starting point. The exposure is.”
Next step: your classroom will now give these ideas formal names—forward, futures, options, swaps, margin, MTM, basis, hedging, speculation and arbitrage.
—